Instagram Ads Audit & Account Restructure (One-Time)
About this service
Your Instagram Ads account is underperforming and you can smell it - the CPM is climbing, the CPC has crept past two dollars, the ROAS has been floating between 1.4 and 1.9 for two quarters, and you are no longer sure which campaigns are doing the work. This engagement is a one-time, fixed-fee diagnostic and restructure deliverable. You receive a 50-point audit, a restructure plan, a prioritized fix-list, and a written rationale for every recommended change. Then you execute - yourself, your in-house team, or a manager you hire separately. There is no ongoing management in this engagement. The deliverable is the product.
I run this on accounts spending between $1,500 and $60,000 per month on Instagram Ads, usually Meta-built campaigns with a mix of Reels, feed, and story placements, often with a Pixel and Conversions API setup that nobody has validated in six months. Over 142 of these audits I have a stable pattern: roughly 8 to 14 of the 50 audit points surface a material issue, and the median account carries between 22% and 41% of its monthly spend on placements, audiences, or creatives that have not produced a single qualified conversion in the last 30-day window. The audit document puts a number on that for your account. The restructure plan tells you what to do about it.
1. What you receive - the deliverable
A single zip of written materials, delivered on day 3. Nothing live is changed inside your account - that is your call after you read the document.
- 50-point audit document (PDF, 18-26 pages). Each of the 50 points is scored Pass / Watch / Fail, with the supporting metric, the benchmark range, and a one-line note. No fluff, no decorative charts.
- Restructure plan (PDF, 8-14 pages). A target campaign architecture: campaign count, ad set granularity, placement mix, audience strategy, bidding strategy per campaign, and the budget split that the data supports. Side-by-side "current" versus "proposed" structure diagram.
- Prioritized fix-list (spreadsheet, CSV + XLSX). Every recommended change as one row, ranked P0 / P1 / P2 by impact and effort, with the metric it should move and the threshold for "fixed".
- Written rationale document (PDF, 6-10 pages). A paragraph of reasoning for every structural recommendation. Not "do this because I said so" - the data, the benchmark, and the trade-off in writing.
- Executive summary (PDF, 1-2 pages). Five numbers up top: total spend last 30 days, waste estimate, EMQ score, top-three issues, top-three opportunities.
- Measurement-health appendix. Pixel events firing, CAPI deduplication rate, EMQ tier, and the gap between ad-platform conversions and your backend source of truth.
- A 25-minute recorded walkthrough (Loom-style link). Screen-shared reading of the audit, the restructure plan, and the fix-list. You can share it with your team or your future manager.
- One revision pass. Within 7 days of delivery, you may request one round of clarifications or depth-additions on up to 8 of the 50 audit points. The 50-point scope itself is fixed at order time.
2. The 50-point audit framework
The framework is stable across all audits - the same 50 points, in the same five categories, so you can compare your account to the benchmark set. Categories and representative points below.
| Category | Points | What it covers | Benchmark ranges used |
|---|---|---|---|
| A. Measurement integrity | 10 | Pixel + CAPI firing, event match quality (EMQ), deduplication rate, conversion action selection, GA4 alignment, iOS-ATT signal loss, server-side event gaps, custom conversion redundancy, test event validation, attribution window setting | EMQ target ≥ 8.0 (Good) / ≥ 9.0 (Excellent); CAPI dedup rate ≥ 90%; platform-to-backend conversion gap ≤ 5% |
| B. Account structure | 10 | Campaign count, ad set granularity, audience overlap, budget concentration, placement separation, Advantage+ vs ABO selection, campaign objective consistency, learning phase entries, ad count per ad set, dynamic creative usage | Active ad sets per campaign: 3-7; ad sets in "Learning Limited" ≤ 20% of total; budget concentration top-1 campaign ≤ 60% |
| C. Creative & ad formats | 10 | Reels/feed/story/Explore mix, hook strength in first 1.5s, CTA usage, text-overlay legibility, aspect-ratio compliance, UGC vs studio mix, creative refresh cadence, ad fatigue flags, dynamic creative elements, music/sound-on discipline | Reels CTR benchmark 0.8%-2.5%; feed CTR 0.4%-1.5%; story swipe-up rate 0.3%-1.2%; refresh cadence ≥ 1 new creative per ad set per 14 days |
| D. Targeting & audiences | 10 | Interest stack breadth, lookalike tier usage, exclusion hygiene, retargeting window lengths, custom audience freshness, audience overlap %, Advantage+ audience eligibility, saved audience vs new, geographic concentration, device/os splits | Lookalike tiers tested: 1% / 3% / 5%; audience overlap ≤ 25% across active ad sets; retargeting windows: 7/14/30/90-day ladder |
| **E. Bidding, budget & pacing | 10 | Bid strategy per campaign, budget allocation logic, learning phase management, ABO vs CBO discipline, frequency caps, dayparting, spend pace, lowest-cost vs cost-cap usage, bid cap discipline, payout window alignment | Frequency ≥ 4 in 7-day window triggers refresh; CPM benchmarks: feed $5-$22, Reels $3-$14, story $4-$18 by vertical |
Every audit point is scored against the benchmark range and against your own 90-day trend - a point can pass the benchmark but still fail on trend (e.g., CTR inside the benchmark but falling for four consecutive weeks).
3. How it works - the three days
- Day 1, hours 0-6: Access and data pull. You grant analyst-level access (no manager access needed - read-only is enough for the audit). I pull 90 days of campaign, ad set, ad, audience, placement, and creative performance data, plus the Pixel diagnostics and CAPI event match quality report from Events Manager.
- Day 1, hours 6-24: Pattern analysis. I work the 50-point framework against your data. Each point gets a provisional score, a supporting metric, and a note. Where the data is ambiguous (e.g., EMQ is borderline), I flag it for the rationale document.
- Day 2: Restructure plan, fix-list, and rationale. Audit findings get translated into a target structure, a prioritized fix-list, and the written reasoning for each recommendation. The executive summary is written last so the numbers in it are final.
- Day 3 morning: Internal QA. A second pass through the 50 points to catch any benchmark misreads and to confirm the fix-list priorities survive a fresh look.
- Day 3 afternoon: Delivery. The zip lands in your inbox through the platform message system. The recorded walkthrough goes out the same day. You have 7 days to use your one revision pass.
4. Who this engagement fits - and who it does not
A strong fit if:
- You spend between $1,500 and $60,000 per month on Instagram Ads and have at least 90 days of accumulated data
- Your account was built by you, a former agency, or a contractor - and you suspect (or know) it has structural debt
- You want a defensible, documented second opinion before you commit to ongoing management
- You have a team - internal or freelance - that can execute the restructure, and you just need the blueprint
A poor fit if:
- Your monthly spend is under $1,200 - at that level the audit cost does not repay itself inside a reasonable window, and I will say so before you order
- You want someone to manage the account on an ongoing basis - that is a different engagement; this one ends on day 3
- You expect a guaranteed ROAS or CPA lift - the audit is a process and a document, not an outcome promise. Any honest practitioner will tell you the same
- Your account is fewer than 60 days old - there is not enough history to audit against the benchmark set
5. You bring / I run - the division of responsibility
This is a management-only engagement in the strictest sense: I deliver a document, you operate the account.
You bring:
- The active Instagram-connected ad account, with billing you control
- Analyst-level (read-only is fine) access for 7 days
- Access to your Events Manager, Pixel configuration, and any backend conversion source (Shopify, your CRM, your analytics) needed to validate the measurement integrity section
- Business context: margins, what counts as a qualified conversion, capacity constraints, seasonal patterns
- A 48-hour response habit for the clarifying questions that come up during analysis
I run:
- The 50-point audit, the restructure plan, the fix-list, the rationale document, the executive summary, and the recorded walkthrough
- The benchmark comparisons and the waste estimation math
- The measurement-health appendix
- One revision pass on up to 8 audit points, within 7 days of delivery
6. What happens after delivery - the explicit one-time boundary
This is a one-time engagement. After day 3, the work is done. You take the restructure plan and the fix-list and you execute it - yourself, your in-house marketer, or a manager you bring in separately. I do not push the changes live for you, I do not run the rebuild, I do not manage the account week-to-week. If you want ongoing management after reading the audit, that is a separate engagement - either with me (a different listing) or with another operator of your choosing. The deliverable is deliberately scoped so the document has all the information a competent manager needs to execute without further consultation.
7. Reporting and communication
Because this is a one-time engagement, there is no weekly report. The audit zip is the report. Communication during the three days happens through the platform message system; I respond within one business day, and most clarifying questions land inside the first 12 hours. After delivery you have 7 days to use your one revision pass; outside that window, follow-up questions are billable as a separate consultation (a different listing).
8. Why this engagement
Three points worth stating plainly. First, the audit comes before any restructuring recommendation. I will not hand you a restructure plan whose measurement integrity section I have not validated - because restructuring on top of broken data is how accounts get worse, not better. Second, every recommendation has a written rationale you can audit. The restructure plan is not "trust me"; it is a paragraph of reasoning per change, attached to a benchmark, attached to a metric in your own data. Third, you own everything. The document is yours. The fix-list is yours. The recorded walkthrough is yours. If you take it to a different manager next week, they can execute from the document alone. That is deliberate.
What is included
- Base Instagram Ads campaign · Your ad account, your spend
- Revisions · 1 round included
- Delivery · 3 to 5 days
Frequently asked questions
Industries served
- Food and Drink
Instagram and Bing management, no lock-in
- Completed orders
- 536
- Rating
- 4.8182 reviews
- Active listings
- 6
- Ad platforms
- 4
More from Amanda Wilson
View storefrontTikTok AdsI Will Turn Your Best TikTok Posts Into Spark Ads That Scale5 to 7 days$249.00
Instagram AdsBeauty & Fashion Brand Instagram Ads Retainer4 to 6 days$349.00
Instagram AdsReels Ads Done-for-You - 30-Day All-Inclusive Campaign10 to 12 days$599.00
Bing Ads30-Day Microsoft Ads Campaign, All-Inclusive30 to 32 days$549.00